|
|
||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||
|
June 2003 |
||||||||||||||||
|
Transferred to www.oscholars.com with minor revisions
December 2008 |
||||||||||||||||
|
The Associate Editor of THE
OSCHOLARS with responsibility for helping with this issue of SHAVINGS was Julie A. Sparks of the Department of
English, University of Arkansas-Monticello. |
||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||
|
‘Oh, Shaw! That’s the man who
smokes Jaeger cigarettes!’ |
||||||||||||||||
|
Note: Subscribers
to this Journal have their names printed in bold, and can be contacted
through us at oscholars@gmail.com. |
||||||||||||||||
|
Click |
||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||
|
In this section we shall try to cover productions of Shaw’s
pre-1901 plays, and news of productions of these (with offers of review) will
be most welcome. The plays are Arms and the Man (1894), Cæsar
and Cleopatra (1898), Candida (1895), Captain Brassbound’s
Conversion (1899), The Devil’s Disciple (1897), The Man of
Destiny (1895), Mrs Warren’s Profession (1893), The Philanderer
(1893), Widowers’ Houses (1892), You Never Can Tell (1895). (Dates
of composition, not first performance.) Wilde is known to have
attended the first night of Arms and the Man (20th April 1894). |
||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||
|
The Shaw Season at Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario, has been
announced. The plays for 2003 will be Widowers’ Houses (15th May to 4th October) and Misalliance
(10th April to 2nd November) . |
||||||||||||||||
|
Mrs Warren’s
Profession |
||||||||||||||||
|
This is the Peter Hall Production, reviewed for us when
in London by Joseph Donohue
(University of Massachusetts, Amherst). Barbara Blethyn is succeeded as
Mrs Warren by Twiggy Lawson. It is now touring as follows: |
||||||||||||||||
|
Malvern Theatres (and
The Cinema, Forum Theatre, Festival Theatre), Malvern |
||||||||||||||||
|
Theatre Royal (and
Ustinov Studio), Bath |
||||||||||||||||
|
Regent Theatre |
||||||||||||||||
|
Richmond Theatre |
||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||
|
Twentieth
Century clippings: |
||||||||||||||||
|
After opening in Pittsburgh on 5th June, the Pittsburgh Irish and Classical Theatre will
be taking a production of Major Barbara, directed by Matt O’Brien, to
Ireland and playing at the Galway Arts Festival and the Pavilion Theatre in
Dún Laoghaire (29th July to 16th August).
Daniel J. Travanti is playing Undershaft, quaintly described in the Pavilion
Theatre’s brochure as a ‘millionaire arts dealer’. |
||||||||||||||||
|
The current London run of My Fair Lady will close
on 30th August. |
||||||||||||||||
|
Michael Friend has staged a number of Shaw’s
plays at Shaw’s Corner, Ayot St Lawrence. Full details of all the
productions, cast lists, photographs, and touring plans for 2003, can be
found at Error! Hyperlink reference not valid..
|
||||||||||||||||
|
Saint Joan will be produced in July.
Adam Bampton-Smith, Lottie Bovingdon, Simon Evison, Phil Gerrard, Moira
Opazo, Roger Ringrose, Peter Saracen. |
||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||
2. Shawlines
|
||||||||||||||||
|
In this section we will print all the news that we find
or, better still, are sent. We especially welcome news of Shaw on
curricula. |
||||||||||||||||
|
We also wish to record articles and papers relating to
the earlier Shaw, and news of new editions of Cashel Byron’s Profession
(1886), An Unsocial Socialist (1887), The Quintessence of Ibsenism
(1891), The Perfect Wagnerite (1898), Love Among the Artists (1900),
as well as other related material. |
||||||||||||||||
|
On 16th May The Bernard Shaw Society in New York
presented scenes from Lady Windermere’s Fan, directed and produced by
Thomas Luce Summa with actors from the Heritage Theatre. Brief excerpts from
Shaw’s reviews of Wilde’s plays preceded the performance. We regret we
learned of this too late for inclusion in the May edition of SHAVINGS, and
thank those readers who alerted us it. |
||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||
|
At the the American Conference for Irish Studies 4th-7th June, Nelson O’Ceallaigh Ritschel
(Massachusetts Maritime Academy ) is giving a paper on ‘J. M. Synge and the
Rewriting of G. B. Shaw: The Playboy’. |
||||||||||||||||
|
Shaw’s Corner at Ayot St Lawrence re-opened for
the season on 2nd April. It
can be contacted at shawscorner@nationaltrust.org.uk
|
||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||
|
The Shaw Birthplace in Dublin re-opens on the 1st May. It can be contacted at shawhouse@dublintourism.ie |
||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||
|
SHAW IN
THE HERE AND NOW |
||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||
|
The Dublin Writers Museum will hold an exhibition devoted
to Shaw and to Sean O’Casey throughout March 2004. If any readers have
memorabilia that they are willing to lend, under the usual guarantees of
security, insurance and proper curatorial care, please contact us. |
||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||
3. A Shaw Anthology
|
||||||||||||||||
|
Echoes of Oscar |
||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||
|
Candida |
||||||||||||||||
|
In Candida, we find a number of
references that draw us back to Wilde, not least in the two leading male
characters, the Revd James Mavor Morell and Eugene Marchbanks. Morell
(like the Revd Stewart Headlam, who went bail for Wilde, and is referred in
the stage directions towards the beginning of Act I) is a Christian
Socialist, but he also has something of a physical resemblance to Wilde at
the height of his powers: |
||||||||||||||||
|
A vigorous, genial, popular man of
forty, robust and goodlooking, full of energy, with pleasant, hearty
considerate manners [. . .] with a wide range and command of expression [ . .
.] His well-spring of enthusiasm and sympathetic emotion has never run dry
for a moment [. . . ] pardonably vain of his powers and unconsciously pleased
with himself [. . .] good forehead [. . .] eyes bright and eager, mouth
resolute but not particularly well cut [. . .] |
||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||
|
But it is Morell’s foil, the poet Marchbanks, who steps
out of the world of the Rhymer’s Club and the Café Royal. The nephew of
an earl (and Eugene of course means well-born, while Marchbanks, in its form ‘Marjoribanks’,
was the family name of Lord Tweedmouth), he is ‘a strange, shy youth of
eighteen, slight, effeminate, with a delicate childish voice, and a hunted
tormented expression and shrinking manner that shew the painful sensitiveness
of very swift and accurate apprehensiveness [. . . .] Miserably irresolute,
he does not know where to stand or what to do [. . .] His nostrils, mouth,
and eyes betray a fiercely petulant wilfulness’. It is not difficult to
give a queer reading to this description, nor to discern there something of ‘Bosie’
Douglas. We do not get much of his poetry, but we are given too
understand that he is an 1890s æsthete when he says to Candida that he should
to give her ‘a boat; a tiny shallop to sail away in, far from the world,
where the marble floors are washed by the rain and dried by the sun; wherre
the south wind dusts the beautiful green and purple carpets. Or a
chariot! to carry us up into the sky, where the lamps are stars.’ This is not
Marchbanks’ only æsthetic conceit: the phrase ‘Let me go now. The night
outside grows impatient’ is very Wildëan. |
|
This strikes Morell as all too high-falutin’, but Candida
reminds Morell that Marchbanks cleans the household’s boots (Marchbanks: ‘Oh
don’t talk about boots! Your feet should be beautiful on the mountains’), and
it will be recalled that Constance Wilde is said to have interrupted a poetic
discourse of Oscar’s by referring to Cyril’s boots. It is not necessary
to believe that she did so (Vyvyan Holland poured scorn on the notion), but
it may have been an ill-natured on dit at the time, unless the story
was a much later fabrication by Frank Harris. The text and and the
anecdote may be at least be read together; just as one cannot learn Morell’s
uncommon middle name without recalling Sidney Mavor, who once spent the night
with Wilde at the Albemarle Hotel. |
|
Morell’s secretary is called Proserpine Garnett (‘a brisk
little woman of the lower middle class’), and acts to some extent as
raisonneuse. Addressed as Miss Prossy, she may be a younger incarnation
of Miss Prism, who also has a pretentious classical first name,
Letitia. Shaw likes to play these little games with names: one thinks
of ‘Rummy’ Mitchens, the broken down old woman in Major Barbara, who was
named after George Eliot’s Romola. |
|
Major Barbara |
|
There is some scope for discussing ‘the most marvellous
of all gospels, the gospel of gold’, as expounded by Baron Arnheim to dazzle
Robert Chiltern, and its use by Andrew Undershaft. Wildëan echoes are
frequent in Major Barbara. |
|
. . . |
|
SIR ROBERT CHILTERN: Believe
me, Mrs. Cheveley, it is a swindle. Let us call things by their proper names.
|
|
UNDERSHAFT: Pooh,
Professor! let us call things by their proper names. |
|
. . . |
|
‘I know how people chatter in England. The middle classes air their moral prejudices over their gross dinner-tables, and whisper about what they call the profligacies of their betters in order to try and pretend that they are in smart society and on intimate terms with the people they slander.’ (Dorian Gray speaking) --
The Picture of Dorian Gray |
|
LADY BRITOMART: ‘It is only in the middle classes that people get in a state of dumb helpless horror when they find that there are wicked people in the world.
-- Major Barbara, Act II |
|
‘Modern morality consists in accepting the standard of one’s age. I consider that for any man of culture to accept the standard of his age is a form of the grossest immorality.’ (Lord Henry Wotton speaking)
-- The Picture of Dorian Gray |
|
MRS CHEVELEY: Nowadays, with our modern mania for morality, every one has to pose as a paragon of purity, incorruptibility, and all the other seven deadly virtues.
-- An Ideal Husband, Act I |
|
CECIL GRAHAM: But scandal is gossip made tedious by morality. Now, I never moralise. A man who moralises is usually a hypocrite, and a woman who moralises is invariably plain.
-- Lady Windermere’s Fan, Act II |
|
LADY BRITOMART: Just as one doesnt mind men practising immorality so long as they own they are in the wrong by preaching morality; so I couldn’t forgive Andrew for preaching immorality while practising morality.
-- Major Barbara, Act I |
|
. . . |
|
GERALD: Mother, this is Lord Illingworth, who has
offered to take me as his private secretary. It is a wonderful opening
for me, isn’t it? |
|
LADY BRACKNELL: I have always been of opinion that a man who desires to get married should know either everything or nothing. Which do you know? JACK: I know nothing, Lady
Bracknell. |
|
UNDERSHAFT: He knows nothing and thinks he knows everything. That points to a political career. Get him a private secretaryship to some one who can get him an Under Secretaryship.
-- Major Barbara, Act III |
|
. . . |
|
LADY BRACKNELL: What
is your income? |
|
LADY BRITOMART: You know how poor my father he is: he has barely seven thousand a year now; and really, if he were not the Earl of Stevenage, he would have to give up society.
-- Major Barbara, Act I |
|
. . . |
|
One should also note that the career of Adolphus Cusins
in Major Barbara turns on his being a foundling, while the future of
Jack Worthing turns on his not being one. |
|
JACK: It is a terrible thing for a
man to find out suddenly that all his life he has been speaking nothing but
the truth. |
|
‘Make any statement that is so true that it has been staring us in the face all our lives, and the whole world will rise up and contradict you.’
-- Too True to be Good, Act II. |
|
Letters |
|
ALGERNON: I wish you would reform
me. You might make that your mission. |
|
‘No fascinating woman
ever wants to emancipate her sex’ |
|
Cashel Byron’s Profession |
|
Cashel Byron’s Profession was written some years
before the greater part of Wilde’s work was undertaken, but it reveals how
Shaw was also dipping into the same pool as Wilde. Here is Lydia Carew
on railway trains: |
|
A train is a beautiful thing.
Its pure white fleece of steam harmonises with every variety of landscape. |
|
|
|
Cashel Byron’s Profession also has a prominent
character called Lord Worthington. Had it been written ten years
later we would have seized on this compound of John Worthing and Lord
Darlington, just as Wilde’s Lady Roxton and Lady Plymdale seem to combine in
Shaw’s Lady Roxdale (Widowers’ Houses). Byron goes to a ‘scholastic
establishment for the sons of gentlemen’ called Moncrief House. |
|
Man and Superman |
|
John Cooper draws our attention to the following: |
|
In this world there
are two tragedies. One is not getting what one wants, and the other is
getting it. The last is much the worst. |
|
There are two
tragedies in life. One is to lose your heart’s desire. The other is to gain
it. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
4. Bibliographies
& Links
|
|
GBS for Wildeans: A
Bibliography of 19th century Shaw. |
|
This will be a cumulative bibliography as references come
to hand. |
|
Beerbohm, Max: Around
Theatres. London: Rupert Hart-Davis 1953. |
|
This carries reviews of plays
published in the Saturday Review, namely The Devil’s Disciple (‘"G.B.S."
at Kennington’, 7th October 1899, pp.38-41; and the 1907 revival ‘Mr.
Vedrenne’, 26th October 1907, pp.481-4); You Never Can Tell (12th May
1900, pp.78-9); the 1901 reprint of Cashel Byron’s Profession (‘A
Cursory Conspectus of G.B.S.’, 2nd November 1901, pp.171-5); Mrs Warren’s
Profession (‘Mr Shaw’s Tragedy’, 1st February 1902, pp. 191-5); the 1907
revival of The Philanderer (9th February 1907 pp.449-51); and the 1908
revival of Arms and the Man (4th January 1908, pp.491-3). There
is also a review of the published edition of Three Plays for Puritans
(The Devil’s Disciple, Cæsar and Cleopatra and Captain Brassbound’s
Conversion) (‘Mr Shaw Crescent’, 26th January 1901, pp. 118-22). |
|
Outside our current range are reviews
of The Doctors’ Dilemma, Getting Married, John Bull’s Other Island, Major
Barbara, Man and Superman, Misalliance, and Pygmalion. |
|
Beerbohm, Max: More Theatres. London: Rupert Hart-Davis 1969.
This volume contains Beerbohm’s pieces for the Saturday Review that he
omitted from the first edition of Around Theatres (1924), an omission
followed in the 1953 edition. |
|
This volume opens with three squibs
against Shaw ‘G.B.S. Oblige’ (9th April 1898, pp.17-21), ‘Mr Shaw’s
Profession’ (14th May 1898, pp.21-4) and ‘Mr Shaw’s Profession II’ (pp.25-7,
21st May 1898). These contain allusions to Arms and the Man
(p.25), Candida (p.26), Mrs Warren’s Profession (pp.21-4, 25), Plays
Pleasant and Unpleasant (p.11), The Devil’s Disciple (pp.21, 335),
The Philanderer (p.21), Widowers’ Houses (21, 25), You Never Can
Tell (pp.25, 26). |
|
There are further references to Mrs
Warren’s Profession (p70), Arms and the Man (p267), Cæsar &
Cleopatra (p.271). |
|
The volume also contains a review of Captain
Brassbound’s Conversion (29th December 1900, pp.335-7). From beyond
our period is The Admirable Bashville (pp.580-2). |
|
Borsa, Mario: The English Stage of To-day. Translated
from the original Italian and edited with a prefatory note by Selwyn Brinton
M.A. London: John Lane The Bodley Head 1908. This has one
chapter on Shaw. |
|
Chapter IV: G.B.S. |
|
Boyd, Ernest A.:
Appreciations and Depreciations, Irish Literary Portraits. Dublin:
Talbot Press & London: T. Fisher Unwin 1919. This has one chapter
on Shaw. |
|
Chapter V: An Irish Protestant,
Bernard Shaw. |
|
Innes, Christopher (ed.): The
Cambridge Companion to George Bernard Shaw. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press 1998. This contains four essays on the younger Shaw:
|
|
Gordon, David J.: Shavian Comedy and the Shadow
of Wilde; |
|
Jackson, Holbrook:
The Eighteen Nineties. 1913. Pelican Books 1939. This
contains a chapter devoted to Shaw. |
|
Chapter XIV: Enter G.B.S. |
|
Kennedy, J.M. English
Literature 1880-1905. London: Stephen Swift 1912. This
contains one chapter on Shaw. |
|
Chapter VI: George Bernard Shaw. |
|
Laurence, Dan H.:
Bernard Shaw, Collected Letters 1874-1897. London: Max Reinhardt
1965. |
|
Laurence, Dan H.:
Bernard Shaw, Collected Letters 1898-1910. London: Max Reinhardt
1972. |
|
Meisel, Martin: Shaw
and the Nineteenth Century Theater. Princeton University Press
1963; new edition New York: Limelight Editions 1984 ISBN 0-87910-017-6. |
|
Morgan, A.L.: Tendencies
of Modern English Drama. London: Constable 1924. This
contains three chapters on Shaw: |
|
Chapter VI.
Shaw the Iconoclast--Dramatic Iconoclast |
|
-- and covering a later period than the pre-1901
Shaw, the following should be mentioned: |
|
Hyde, Mary (ed.): Bernard
Shaw and Alfred Douglas, A Correspondence. London: John Murray 1982. |
|
Weintraub, Stanley (ed.):
The Playwright and the Pirate, Bernard Shaw and Frank Harris, A
Correspondence. Pittsburgh: Pennsylvania State University Press and
Gerrards Cross: Colin Smythe 1982. |
|
This covers not only Harris’s ‘biography’
of Shaw but the attempts of Harris to involve Shaw in his book on
Wilde. The first letter in this collection is Harris to Shaw 30th
November 1898. The second (Shaw to Harris 4th November 1900) gives Shaw’s
views on Mr and Mrs Daventry. There is one more
letter from this period (Shaw to Harris 16th December 1900); the
correspondence resumes in December 1904. |
|
The following bring together Shaw and Wilde: |
|
Bader, Earl Delbert: ‘The Self-Reflexive
Language: uses of Paradox in Wilde, Shaw and Chesterton .’ Ph. D.
dissertation. Indiana University 1962. |
|
Beckson, Karl: ‘Oscar Wilde’s Celebrated Remark on
Bernard Shaw.’ Notes and Queries 41(239): 3 Oxford 1994. |
|
Gollin, Richard M.: ‘Beerbohm, Wilde, Shaw and "The
Good-Natured Critic".’ Bulletin of the New York Public Library
68, New York February 1964. |
|
Harris, Frank: Oscar Wilde, including My Memories of
Oscar Wilde by George Beranrd Shaw. Carroll: New York 1997. |
|
Harris, Frank: Oscar Wilde: His Life & Confessions,
with memories of Oscar Wilde by Bernard Shaw and Criticisms by Robert
Ross. The author, 2nd edition, the first with the pieces by Shaw and
Ross. New York 1918. |
|
Harris, Frank: Oscar Wilde: His Life &
Confessions. Together with Memories of Wilde by Bernard Shaw. The
author. London 1918. |
|
Harris, Frank: Oscar Wilde: His Life &
Confessions. Together with Memories of Wilde by Bernard Shaw. New York:
Crown Publishing Co. 1930. |
|
Hill, John Edward: ‘Dialectical Æstheticism — Essays on
the Criticism of Swinburne, Pater, Wilde, James, Shaw and Yeats’.
University of Virginia Thesis Virginia 1972. |
|
Jordan, John: ‘Shaw, Wilde, Synge and Yeats: Ideas,
Epigrams, Blackberries and Chassis’ Wolfhound in The Irish Mind; Exploring
Intellectual Traditions Dublin 1985. |
|
Koritz, Amy E.: ‘Gendering Bodies, Performing Art:
Theatrical Dancing and the Performance Æsthetics of Wilde, Shaw & Yeats’.
Dissertation Abstracts International 50 : 3 [North Carolina 1988] Ann Arbor
1989. |
|
Lee, Josephine D.: ‘Language & Action in the Plays of
Wilde, Shaw & Stoppard.’ Dissertation Abstracts International 48 :
7 Ann Arbor 1988. |
|
Livermore, Ann: ‘Goldoni, Wilde and Shaw:
Co-Inventors of Comedy.’ Revue de la Littérature Comparée 53 |
|
Loughney, Martin: Springs of Irish Wisdom: Shaw, Wilde,
Swift, Yeats. Dublin: Infinity Books 1989. |
|
Nassaar, Christopher Suhal: ‘Wilde’s Lady
Windermere’s Fan and Shaw’s Mrs Warren’s Profession.’ Explicator
56 |
|
Powell, Kerry: ‘Wilde, Shaw and Women of the
Stage.’ William Andrews Clark Memorial Library Conference: Oscar Wilde
and the Culture of the Fin-de-Siècle, Session II Los Angeles 5th March 1999. |
|
Roy, Emil: British Drama Since Shaw [Chapter on The
Importance of Being Earnest] Carbondale and London : Southern Illinois
U.P. & Feffer and Simons 1972. |
|
Ruff, William: ‘Shaw on Wilde and Morris, A Clarification’
Shaw Review 11 : 1 January 1968. |
|
Sherard, Robert Harborough: Bernard Shaw, Frank Harris
& Oscar Wilde. New York 1936. |
|
Sherard, Robert Harborough: Bernard Shaw, Frank Harris
& Oscar Wilde. T. Werner Laurie London 1937. |
|
Sherard, Robert Harborough: Oscar Wilde ‘Drunkard &
Swindler’: A Reply to George Bernard Shaw, Dr G.J. Renier, Frank Harris etc.
Calvi: Vindex Publishing Co. 1933. |
|
Weintraub, Stanley: ‘"The Hibernian School":
Oscar Wilde and Bernard Shaw.’ SHAW: The Annual of Bernard Shaw
Studies 13 1993. |
|
Weintraub, Stanley: Shaw’s People:
Victoria to Churchill. University Park, Pennsylvania: 1996. |
|
Wisenthal, J. L.: ‘Wilde, Shaw and the Play of
Conversation Modern Drama.’ (U. of Toronto Graduate Centre for Study of
Drama) 37:1 Downsview, Ontario Spring 1994. |
|
We welcome
additions and corrections, and would much like to hear from any of the
writers still living. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
A list of websites kindly
provided by Richard Dietrich (University of South Florida): |
|
BERNARD SHAW SOCIETY
WEB SITE (see illustration below): |
|
UNIVERSITY PRESS OF FLORIDA SHAW
SERIES WEB SITE: |
|
SHAW BIZNESS WEB SITE: |
|
INTERNATIONAL SHAW SOCIETY WEB
SITE: |
|
THE SHAW FESTIVAL |
|
UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH FLORIDA SHAW
CONFERENCE 2004 AT SARASOTA: |
|
BRITISH DRAMA 1890-1950: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The Bernard Shaw Society may be reached at P.O. Box 1159,
Madison Square Station New York, N.Y. 10159-1159 |
|
|
|
The Society publishes The Independent Shavian. The
image below is the latest one on their website (vol.40 nos 2-3. 2002). |
|
|
|
The Independent Shavian appears three times a
year and is sent to all members of the Bernard Shaw Society at no charge as
part of their membership dues. |
|
What we have previously referred to as the The
Irish Shaw Society should correctly have been called The Dublin Shaw
Society. This maintains no website but may be contacted through the
Hon. Secretary. Mary Casey has now succeeded Breda O’Brien in this post
(no address as yet available). The Society meets on the third Wednesday
of every month in the United Arts Club, 3 Fitzwilliam Street, Dublin 2.
Membership is €15 p.a., for an individual, €35 for a couple. On Wednesday 18th June Brian McGrath and Una
Minto will perform ‘Shaw and Recocnilable Differences’. |
|
Plans are taking shape to re vamp the Society, and
anybody interested should contact the Chairman, Brian Mc Grath <bricar@gofree.indigo.ie> |
|
|
6. TAILPIECE
|
|
‘England is the land of intellectual fogs but you have
done much to clear the air: we are both Celtic, and I like to think that we
are friends.’ |
|
– Oscar Wilde to George Bernard Shaw to Oscar Wilde
(‘My dear Shaw’) 23rd February 1893; in Merlin Holland &
Rupert Hart-Davis: The Complete Letters of Oscar Wilde. London:
Fourth Estate 2000. p.554. |
|
|
|
|
|
|